Originally Posted by
dude02
Would not have wood as as stated above due to maintenance (though they can be beautiful).
Also agree that 14' is too short for three guys. A 16 x 54 aluminum is as small as I would go for three people. The rear stands in a 16 x 54 can be a bit close to the rower. For three guys, a 17 x 60 is much more comfortable. I've drifted the Trinity multiple times in both sizes. Both would be fine meaning that there would be no penalty for the bigger boat. The Lower Sac, Feather, and the Yuba are all easily drifted in this size, but I have no experience on rivers further south. I know some rivers are quite small and may be better served with rafts.
The bulk of all Clackacrafts are 16' models and measure more similarly to 17' aluminum boats. No problem on the Trinity. My guess is its the same for Hyde and other glass boats.
Lots of threads on the web on the aluminum vs. fiberglass debate. I've only been in Clackacraft and Willie boats and can't speak for the rest. Both of these manufacturers make great boats. I prefer glass but honestly if I were buying used I would look for the best deal either way. Most used glass boats tend to be set up for fly fishing whereas used aluminum boats see a mix of fly and non-fly set ups. It is not particularly comfortable nor safe to fish without braces and this can add some cost to remedy.
If the budget allows, buy the best oars you can afford. It is a night and day difference between the basic Carlisles that came with the Clack and a set of Sawyer MSXG's with Dynalite blades. Sawyer Square Tops with Dynalite blades would also be a killer set up. Shoal cut if you float lots of skinny water like the Trinity. Seriously, a nice set of oars makes the day a whole lot nicer.
Let us know what you end up with.
Bookmarks