Fishing for steelhead is just like fishing for any other species that are willingly ingesting the fly in that the fish follow feeding and reactive behavior that is driven totally by instinct and environmental conditions. Their instincts are totally driven by and geared towards survival, and their behavior and the environmental conditions that govern said behavior both follows patterns that are often predictable.
The notion that pattern doesn’t matter (IF the amount of fish you’re catching matters to you) flies in the face of angling wisdom and critical thinking IMO.
For instance, on the Klamath when the Iso population in the lower and mid river begins to pop and the fall fish are up migrating through significant numbers of Isos movement, floatillas of emerging Isos, and duns getting blown onto the surface, do you really believe some dude fishing a popsicle (all other factors and methods being equal) is going to have the same success as someone that is paying attention to detail and fishing Iso sized Hiltons or herl bodied traditional patterns that actually resemble Isos?
Do you think that an angler tossing a Rea’s Rusty or Olive Muddler is going to have the same success as an angler tossing a Babine Special when fishing a rif below a tailout where dozens of Chinooks are actively tearing up the substrate and digging redds? On a typical spring day when the river is full of free swimming YOY who are you betting on here? Do the odds not shift to the angler tossing the Muddler?
If you’re fishing the upper T in late Nov- early Dec and you’re seeing lots of hatching ephemerella (even if the hatch isn’t strong enough to put the fish up on the emergers/duns) do you think you’re going to have as more success swinging an Ugly Bug or PT nymph?
Would you expect someone swinging a Winter’s Hope to do as well as someone swinging a sac fry pattern during the first heavy storm of the winter that dumps a lot of sediment over incubating substrate and causes a massive allevin emergence before they’re zipped up?
I’ve seen KMP summer fish so locked in and selective to both ephemerella and caddis hatches that they would not only ignore anything besides patterns that mimic those inverts but would only take patterns that mimicked specific life stages of those inverts.
Ed Ward may be a casting guru, but if it’s true that he only fishes variations of one pattern, he’s no steelhead guru.
I think it’s obviously true that anadromous O. Mykiss are generally more aggressive and thus less selective than are O. Mykiss that follow completely riverine life histories, but they do follow predictable patterns of behavior which includes being selective or at the very least preferential to the biomass of biota that they’re seeing being the dominant components of the drift.
The anglers who pay attention to detail and adjust their approach based on conditions to exploit all factors that they are observing that can influence steelhead behavior, are always going to outfish the anglers who hack and cast all season long with a handful of pet patterns (because they believe that pattern doesn’t matter) over a long enough timeline.
Ultimately I think your question is relative to what you envision as success as a steelhead angler. If you’re one of those romantic types that believes that steelhead should be the fish of a 1000 casts and that steelhead are the emblematic bastions of all things good about all things wild and are like aquatic sacred cows and should only be pursued with a myriad of self-imposed limitations, I’d agree pattern probably doesn’t matter. You’ll catch a few fish to a few dozen fish a year and probably be happy with that.
If your goal is to be high rod on the river as many days as possible during the season, subscribing to the notion that pattern doesn’t matter and limiting yourself to fishing one pattern or a few patterns is akin to being a repair contractor without a truck full of tools because you own a Leatherman. The Leatherman might serve as a serviceable tool for all your requirements, but it’s rarely going to be the ideal tool. And the few to a few dozen fish you’re able to catch likely isn’t going to lead to many days where you felt like you were high rod on the river.
Bookmarks