Gentleman,
I first have to say that I don’t know which project your tagged salmon came from (the only DWR tagging I know of uses unmarked acoustic tags), but I'll bet that Matt is right about this. I would like to provide some clarifying information for you all:
In order to generate sufficient returns on tagging studies such as this, hundreds, if not thousands, of fish need to be tagged. Most are tagged as smolts (~6” long), and are thus not capable of carrying a heavy tag with all of the project information listed on it. In addition, each agency usually has one ‘tagging coordinator,’ who can receive 100’s of tags from a across the state; to compound the issue, a number of these tags are mistakenly reported to the wrong person or even agency (DWR vs CDFW vs USFWS). As a result, even if the biologist is in the office when you call (remember, their job is to study fish, which involves time out with the fish), they might not know what the tag is from without some extensive searching. This is just a pretty good example of the need to walk in someone’ shoes before rendering judgment; most of these biologists are working incredibly long, hard hours to accomplish their jobs.
Most fisheries biologists that I know are genuinely concerned with the resource, and many are fisherman themselves. We should be natural allies (we all want more fish), so please be less confrontational about this. A number of these people take significant pay cuts to remain in government service, a sacrifice many of them make because they truly believe that they are doing the right thing.
With the drought and the increased demand on our water infrastructure, information on salmon movement and survival (which is measured by tag returns) is increasingly valuable. I encourage anyone who catches a tagged fish to report it; hopefully the tagging coordinator will be able let you know where the fish came from, but please try to be understanding about his/her limitations. Regardless, if the fisheries managers are getting bad data, they will not be able to make the best management decisions, which directly impacts you and I's fishin.
I checked with a friend of mine who is a DWR fisheries biologist, and he did not know where the tag was from. I’ll keep an ear open for any other tagging studies in the area.
Finally, I believe most of DWR’s research is funded by water contractors, not tax payers…. This is largely semantics, but I feel like it is important to know where the money comes from.
They shoot canoes, don't they?
-Nick
Bookmarks