I have bought about 5 pairs of guide waders from simms. They gave us a bro deal on the g3's 3 years ago and those leaked also. I like patagonia because I like the company, those leak to. I spend about 50-70 days guiding on the pit and nothing really holds up to blackberries. Go with what is comfortable, Hodgeman is giving you a brand new pair, I would be surprised if simms ever did that. I know Orvis will replace waders also and so will Cabelas(they make great stuff and stand by it). Simms has the name and fancy adds but their customer service has something to be desired. If you want to look cool buy simms if you really fish alot then buy some aquaseal.
Bill Downs
Fly Fishing Guide
20322 Grogan St
Burney Ca 96013
Bookmarks